WoRMS source details

Lawley, J. W.; Gamero-Mora, E.; Maronna, M. M.; Chiaverano, L. M.; Stampar, S. N.; Hopcroft, R. R.; Collins, A. G.; Morandini, A. C. (2021). The importance of molecular characters when morphological variability hinders diagnosability: systematics of the moon jellyfish genus Aurelia (Cnidaria: Scyphozoa). PeerJ. 9: e11954.
412857
10.7717/peerj.11954 [view]
Lawley, J. W.; Gamero-Mora, E.; Maronna, M. M.; Chiaverano, L. M.; Stampar, S. N.; Hopcroft, R. R.; Collins, A. G.; Morandini, A. C.
2021
The importance of molecular characters when morphological variability hinders diagnosability: systematics of the moon jellyfish genus Aurelia (Cnidaria: Scyphozoa)
PeerJ
9: e11954
Publication
Cryptic species have been detected across Metazoa, and while no apparent morphological features distinguish them, it should not impede taxonomists from formal descriptions. We accepted this challenge for the jellyfish genus Aurelia, which has a long and confusing taxonomic history. We demonstrate that morphological variability in Aurelia medusae overlaps across very distant geographic localities. Even though some morphological features seem responsible for most of the variation, regional geographic patterns of dissimilarities are lacking. This is further emphasized by morphological differences found when comparing lab-cultured Aurelia coerulea medusae with the diagnostic features in its recent redescription. Previous studies have also highlighted the difficulties in distinguishing Aurelia polyps and ephyrae, and their morphological plasticity. Therefore, mostly based on genetic data, we recognize 28 species of Aurelia, of which seven were already described, 10 are formally described herein, four are resurrected and seven remain undescribed. We present diagnostic genetic characters for all species and designate type materials for newly described and some resurrected species. Recognizing moon jellyfish diversity with formal names is vital for conservation efforts and other studies. This work clarifies the practical implications of molecular genetic data as diagnostic characters, and sheds light on the patterns and processes that generate crypsis.
RIS (EndNote, Reference Manager, ProCite, RefWorks)
BibTex (BibDesk, LaTeX)
Date
action
by
2021-09-10 20:09:48Z
created

Aurelia Lamarck, 1816 (additional source)
Aurelia ayla Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Aurelia cebimarensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Aurelia coerulea von Lendenfeld, 1884 (additional source)
Aurelia columbia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Aurelia hyalina Brandt, 1835 (additional source)
Aurelia insularia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Aurelia limbata Brandt, 1835 (additional source)
Aurelia malayensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Aurelia mianzani Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Aurelia miyakei Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Aurelia montyi Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Aurelia persea (Forsskål, 1775) (status source)
Aurelia rara Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Aurelia smithsoniana Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 (original description)
Angra dos Reis for Aurelia insularia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Bocas del Toro for Aurelia smithsoniana Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Bonaire for Aurelia ayla Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021  (origin: native)
Chukchi Sea for Aurelia hyalina Brandt, 1835 
Dauphin Island for Aurelia montyi Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Dauphin Island for Aurelia rara Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Gulf of Mexico for Aurelia marginalis Agassiz, 1862 
Gulf of Mexico for Aurelia montyi Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Gulf of Thailand for Aurelia miyakei Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021  (origin: native)
Haifa Bay for Aurelia persea (Forsskål, 1775) 
Hawaiian Islands for Aurelia malayensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Ilhabela for Aurelia insularia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Key Largo for Aurelia insularia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Key West for Aurelia marginalis Agassiz, 1862 
Malay Archipelago for Aurelia malayensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Marshall Is. for Aurelia miyakei Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Mediterranean Sea for Aurelia solida Browne, 1905  (origin: alien)
New Ireland Province for Aurelia clausa Lesson, 1830 
Northwestern Pacific for Aurelia columbia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Palau Islands for Aurelia clausa Lesson, 1830 
Palawan for Aurelia malayensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Red Sea for Aurelia dubia Vanhöffen, 1888 
Red Sea for Aurelia solida Browne, 1905 
Samborombon Bay for Aurelia mianzani Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
San Juan Island for Aurelia columbia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Sao Sebastiao Channel for Aurelia cebimarensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Sao Sebastiao Channel for Aurelia mianzani Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
South Japan for Aurelia malayensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021 
Holotype UF 12778, geounit San Juan Island, identified as Aurelia columbia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Holotype USNM 1622161, geounit Bonaire, identified as Aurelia ayla Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Neotype USNM 1643575, geounit Chukchi Sea, identified as Aurelia hyalina Brandt, 1835
Holotype USNM 1643581, geounit Dauphin Island, identified as Aurelia montyi Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype USNM 1643582, geounit Dauphin Island, identified as Aurelia montyi Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype USNM 1643583, geounit Dauphin Island, identified as Aurelia montyi Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Holotype USNM 1643584, geounit Dauphin Island, identified as Aurelia rara Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype USNM 1643585, geounit Dauphin Island, identified as Aurelia rara Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Holotype NHMUK 1948.10.1.239, geounit Maldives Exclusive Economic Zone, identified as Aurelia solida Browne, 1905
Paratype MZUSP 8643, geounit Sao Sebastiao Channel, identified as Aurelia cebimarensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Holotype MZUSP 8644, geounit Sao Sebastiao Channel, identified as Aurelia cebimarensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype MZUSP 8645, geounit Sao Sebastiao Channel, identified as Aurelia cebimarensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype MZUSP 8646, geounit Sao Sebastiao Channel, identified as Aurelia cebimarensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype MZUSP 8647, geounit Angra dos Reis, identified as Aurelia insularia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Holotype MZUSP 8648, geounit Angra dos Reis, identified as Aurelia insularia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype MZUSP 8649, geounit Angra dos Reis, identified as Aurelia insularia Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Holotype MZUSP 8650, geounit Palawan, identified as Aurelia malayensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype MZUSP 8651, geounit Palawan, identified as Aurelia malayensis Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Holotype MZUSP 8652, geounit Sao Sebastiao Channel, identified as Aurelia mianzani Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype MZUSP 8653, geounit Sao Sebastiao Channel, identified as Aurelia mianzani Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Holotype MZUSP 8654, geounit Gulf of Thailand, identified as Aurelia miyakei Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Paratype MZUSP 8655, geounit Gulf of Thailand, identified as Aurelia miyakei Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Holotype MZUSP 8656, geounit Bocas del Toro, identified as Aurelia smithsoniana Lawley, Gamero-Mora, Maronna, Chiaverano, Stampar, Hopcroft, Collins & Morandini, 2021
Neotype MZUSP 8657, geounit Helgoland, identified as Aurelia aurita (Linnaeus, 1758)
Neotype MZUSP 8660, verbatimGeounit Okirai bay, Ofunato,..., identified as Aurelia limbata Brandt, 1835
 Diagnosis

There were 20 diagnostic positions for 16S and 20 for COI [details]

 Diagnosis

There were five diagnostic positions for 16S, four for COI and 16 for ITS1 [details]

 Diagnosis

There were 20 diagnostic positions for 16S, 17 for COI, 18 for ITS1 and four for 28S [details]

 Diagnosis

There were eight diagnostic positions for 16S and 20 for ITS1 [details]

 Diagnosis

There were 12 diagnostic positions for COI and 19 for ITS1 [details]

 Diagnosis

Polyps present 27–33 tentacles (Table S8; see remarks below). There were 20 diagnostic positions for 16S, 20 for ... [details]

 Diagnosis

There were 13 diagnostic positions for COI [details]

 Diagnosis

There were 20 diagnostic positions for 16S, 17 for COI, 18 for ITS1 and four for 28S [details]

 Diagnosis

There were 10 diagnostic positions for 16S, 19 for COI and five for 28S [details]

 Diagnosis

There were 17 diagnostic positions for 16S, 20 for COI, 20 for ITS1 and 17 for 28S [details]

 Diagnosis

There were five diagnostic positions for 16S, 11 for COI and six for ITS1 [details]

 Diagnosis

There were 13 diagnostic positions for 16S, 20 for COI and three for 28S [details]

 Diagnosis

There were six diagnostic positions for 16S and 18 for COI [details]

 Diagnosis

There were 10 diagnostic positions for 16S and seven for COI [details]

 Diagnosis

Absence of an endodermal ocellus on the subumbrellar side of rhopalia (Scorrano et al., 2016; see remarks below). ... [details]

 Etymology

Derived from the Turkish word ayla, meaning “halo of light around the moon”, in honor of the daughter of AGC ... [details]

 Etymology

Named after the Centro de Biologia Marinha (CEBIMar) of the University of São Paulo, situated exactly where the ... [details]

 Etymology

Named after British Columbia, where most of the sequenced specimens have been collected. [details]

 Etymology

Derived from the Latin word insularis, meaning “of islands”, in reference to the recorded occurrence of polyps ... [details]

 Etymology

Named after the Malay Archipelago, situated between mainland Indo-China and Australia, which includes the type ... [details]

 Etymology

In honor of Dr. Hermes W. Mianzan (INIDEP, Argentina), who collected some of the sequenced specimens of this ... [details]

 Etymology

Named after Prof. Dr. Hiroshi Miyake (Kitasato University, Japan), for his prominent research on jellyfish and ... [details]

 Etymology

Named after Dr. William “Monty” Graham (Florida Institute of Oceanography, USA), who was a pioneer in ... [details]

 Etymology

Derived from the Latin word rarus, meaning “rare” or “uncommon”, due to its elusive occurrence among the ... [details]

 Etymology

Named after the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute, in Bocas del Toro, Panama, which has supported studies in ... [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia BOR lineage Schroth et al., 2002. Aurelia borealis Schroth et al., 2002. [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia sp. 2 Dawson & Jacobs, 2001. Dawson, 2003; Dawson, Gupta & England, 2005; Morandini et al., 2005; Ki et al., 2008; Bayha et ... [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia sp. 6 Dawson & Jacobs, 2001. Dawson, 2003; Dawson, Gupta & England, 2005; Ki et al., 2008; Häussermann, Dawson & ... [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia ARAB lineage Schroth et al., 2002. Dawson, 2003; Dawson, Gupta & England, 2005. [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia limbata Dawson & Jacobs, 2001. Aurelia sp. 10 Dawson, Gupta & England, 2005. Ki et al., 2008; Häussermann, ... [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia sp. 4 Dawson & Jacobs, 2001. Dawson, 2003; Dawson, Gupta & England, 2005; Ki et al., 2008; Ramšak, Stopar & Malej, 2012; ... [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia sp. 9 Dawson, Gupta & England, 2005. Ki et al., 2008; Ramšak, Stopar & Malej, 2012; Dong, Liu & Liu, 2015; He et al., ... [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia sp. AA2501 South West Atlantic Ramšak, Stopar & Malej, 2012. Aurelia sp. 16 Gómez-Daglio & Dawson, 2017. ... [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia MCA lineage Schroth et al., 2002. Dawson, Gupta & England, 2005. Aurelia sp. 11 Dawson, Gupta & England, ... [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia sp. Mizrahi, 2014. [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia sp. DI’03-4 Chiaverano, Bayha & Graham, 2016. [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia sp. Benovic et al., 2000. Malej et al., 2007; Turk et al., 2008; Tinta et al., 2010 (Big Lake). Aurelia sp. 5 ... [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia sp. 15 Gómez-Daglio & Dawson, 2017. Abboud, Gómez-Daglio & Dawson, 2018; Dong, 2018. [details]

 Synonymy

Aurelia TET lineage Schroth et al., 2002. Aurelia sp. 8 Dawson, Gupta & England, 2005. Ramšak, Stopar & Malej, 2012; ... [details]