WoRMS name details
Loimia montagui McIntosh, 1922
1522995 (urn:lsid:marinespecies.org:taxname:1522995)
unaccepted (superfluous replacement name for Terebella constrictor Montagu)
Species
marine, brackish, fresh, terrestrial
recent only
McIntosh, W.C. 1922. A monograph of the British marine annelids. Polychaeta: Hermellidae to Sabellidae. London, Ray Society Vol. 4(1) pp.1-250. , available online at https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/page/37485111
page(s): 147-149, plate CXIX fig. 5, plate CXXVI figs. 1, 1a [details]
page(s): 147-149, plate CXIX fig. 5, plate CXXVI figs. 1, 1a [details]
Note McIntosh (1922) does not state the type...
From editor or global species database
Type locality McIntosh (1922) does not state the type locality of the species nor seems to designate type material, but refers the species to be present along the "Devon coast, as Terebella constrictor (Montagu); Plymouth (Baird); Plymouth (Spence Bate and B. Rowe); Yealm shore, Plymouth (Allen)" (McIntosh, 1922: 147). The material used for the original description was at least partially from Plymouth (McIntosh, 1922: figure legend of plate CXIX fig. 5, as "Plymouth"), and in the collections of the Natural History Museum UK, there is material from Plymouth labeled as "Loimia montagui McIntosh" (catalogue number 1921.5.1.3921-3922) and identified by W.C. McIntosh himself, which could represent at least part of the type material used by the author for the description of the new species. It seems thus reasonable to consider the type locality of Loimia montagui McIntosh, 1922 as being the region of Plymouth (Devon, UK, English Channel; gazetteer estimate 50.35°, -4.15°). [details]
Distribution English Channel: Devon coast, including Plymouth and Yealm shore.
Homonymy The combination Loimia montagui (Grube, 1878) is a secondary senior homonym to Loimia montagui McIntosh, 1922. However, it...
Taxonomy Loimia montagui is a superfluous replacement name. McIntosh (1922: 147) indicates his Loimia montagui is a "nom nov". We...
Distribution English Channel: Devon coast, including Plymouth and Yealm shore. [details]
Homonymy The combination Loimia montagui (Grube, 1878) is a secondary senior homonym to Loimia montagui McIntosh, 1922. However, it...
Homonymy The combination Loimia montagui (Grube, 1878) is a secondary senior homonym to Loimia montagui McIntosh, 1922. However, it does not affect the McIntosh species name as it is a recombination of the unreplaced junior primary homonym Terebella montagui Grube, 1878, and as such it is an invalid name. [details]
Taxonomy Loimia montagui is a superfluous replacement name. McIntosh (1922: 147) indicates his Loimia montagui is a "nom nov". We...
Taxonomy Loimia montagui is a superfluous replacement name. McIntosh (1922: 147) indicates his Loimia montagui is a "nom nov". We can only interpret this as a 'nomen novum' intended to replace an existing name. McIntosh otherwise in the British Annelid monographs used “n. s.’ or “N. S.” for new species (nova species). The name apparently being replaced is Terebella constrictor Montagu, hence 'montagui' as the replacement name of it. However, Terebella constrictor Montagu does not need replacement, hence McIntosh's Loimia montagui is a superfluous replacement name and thus a junior synonym of Terebella constrictor. Elsewhere in the same work McIntosh (1922: 166) makes Terebella constrictor Montagu a junior synonym of Terebella lapidaria Linnaeus (also as Leprea lapidaria). These two different treatments of exactly the same name create an irreconcilable situation. [details]
Read, G.; Fauchald, K. (Ed.) (2024). World Polychaeta Database. Loimia montagui McIntosh, 1922. Accessed through: World Register of Marine Species at: https://www.marinespecies.org/aphia.php?p=taxdetails&id=1522995 on 2024-04-24
The webpage text is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License
original description
McIntosh, W.C. 1922. A monograph of the British marine annelids. Polychaeta: Hermellidae to Sabellidae. London, Ray Society Vol. 4(1) pp.1-250. , available online at https://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/page/37485111
page(s): 147-149, plate CXIX fig. 5, plate CXXVI figs. 1, 1a [details]
page(s): 147-149, plate CXIX fig. 5, plate CXXVI figs. 1, 1a [details]
From editor or global species database
Distribution English Channel: Devon coast, including Plymouth and Yealm shore. [details]Homonymy The combination Loimia montagui (Grube, 1878) is a secondary senior homonym to Loimia montagui McIntosh, 1922. However, it does not affect the McIntosh species name as it is a recombination of the unreplaced junior primary homonym Terebella montagui Grube, 1878, and as such it is an invalid name. [details]
Taxonomy Loimia montagui is a superfluous replacement name. McIntosh (1922: 147) indicates his Loimia montagui is a "nom nov". We can only interpret this as a 'nomen novum' intended to replace an existing name. McIntosh otherwise in the British Annelid monographs used “n. s.’ or “N. S.” for new species (nova species). The name apparently being replaced is Terebella constrictor Montagu, hence 'montagui' as the replacement name of it. However, Terebella constrictor Montagu does not need replacement, hence McIntosh's Loimia montagui is a superfluous replacement name and thus a junior synonym of Terebella constrictor. Elsewhere in the same work McIntosh (1922: 166) makes Terebella constrictor Montagu a junior synonym of Terebella lapidaria Linnaeus (also as Leprea lapidaria). These two different treatments of exactly the same name create an irreconcilable situation. [details]
Type locality McIntosh (1922) does not state the type locality of the species nor seems to designate type material, but refers the species to be present along the "Devon coast, as Terebella constrictor (Montagu); Plymouth (Baird); Plymouth (Spence Bate and B. Rowe); Yealm shore, Plymouth (Allen)" (McIntosh, 1922: 147). The material used for the original description was at least partially from Plymouth (McIntosh, 1922: figure legend of plate CXIX fig. 5, as "Plymouth"), and in the collections of the Natural History Museum UK, there is material from Plymouth labeled as "Loimia montagui McIntosh" (catalogue number 1921.5.1.3921-3922) and identified by W.C. McIntosh himself, which could represent at least part of the type material used by the author for the description of the new species. It seems thus reasonable to consider the type locality of Loimia montagui McIntosh, 1922 as being the region of Plymouth (Devon, UK, English Channel; gazetteer estimate 50.35°, -4.15°). [details]
